Never More Divided

Almost daily we are told by some pundit somewhere, that we “have never been more divided.” I think that intellectually we know that isn’t true. But history is past, not always prologue. And without any experiential relationship to it, we find it easy to disconnect from it. We don’t know what happened, except in the broadest of sense, and so it is easy to both ignore its lessons and – like a teenager after a first breakup – believe that nobody could possibly understand what we are going through right now. 

When it comes to the American Civil War of 1861-1865, there are any number of passions, beliefs, arguments, nostalgic wanderings and even warmed over arguments that it’s hard sometimes to keep it all straight. If you want to really start an argument by dropping a grenade into a conversation, just bring up any of the controversial aspects of the Civil War (my personal favorite is, “Could the South have won?”). Then walk over and get your popcorn.

Here we are, one hundred and fifty-two years after the end of the War, and now we have decided that Confederate Monuments need to come down because, hurt feelings. I guess.

Look. I’ll be the second person to say it: Confederate Monuments are the ultimate Participation Trophy. Literally they say “2nd Place, American Civil War.” And while I will also argue that the Confederate States of America was an evil thing in its time, what exactly does tearing down monuments actually accomplish? Supporters of the monuments claim that we can “learn from them.” Fine. Conversely, What is the lesson a person takes away from a statue of Jefferson Davis? 

If education and enlightenment are to be our focus, instead of “feelings” and emotions, when we tear down all of these monuments because, hurt feelings, with what do we replace them? More importantly, when we erase this history, regardless of its stench, what gets reinforced in our corporate minds? That we have never “been more divided?”


Posted on May 11, 2017, in 1st Amendment, American, Civil War, Constitution, Federalism, Freedom of speech, History, Revolutionary War and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink. 2 Comments.

  1. Betsey Dahlberg

    I find this an excellent point, Dave, especially since it is one I have made in other conversations.


  2. “Confederate Monuments are the ultimate Participation Trophy.”
    I actually startled the dog when I laughed at this. It is funny, when you think of the irony – the generation notoriously raised on “participation trophies” has found offence at historic examples. Of course, that would be minimizing the trauma of the past, but… isn’t that what the endgame is for the removal of these statues?

    “More importantly, when we erase this history, regardless of its stench, what gets reinforced in our corporate minds? That we have never ‘been more divided?'”
    My opinions on this topic have been somewhat limited in sharing mostly because many people will only resort to the soundbites from whichever network news they follow. I broke down a few weeks ago and wrote about it (, but the situation hasn’t improved much since then – the next “big story” cycle has repeated several times since then.
    The “division” you speak of will only get worse as people continue to surrender their intellectual free will on the altar of “fear” and “outrage.” These two surrogates for the history we erase, in my opinion, may lead to even more investigation for the next controversial aspect of history to be targeted. What that may be, I have no idea, but it has been quite clear that society can and *will* settle for revision before appreciation.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: